Board Seats and Protective Provisions: Who Really Runs the Company After the Round
Founders often focus on owning more than half the shares. Control after a venture round depends more on the board and a short list of vetoes than on percentages.
A founder who still owns 60 percent of the company after a Series A can be outvoted on the decisions that matter most. That surprises people, but it follows directly from two parts of the term sheet: the board composition clause and the protective provisions. Together, they decide who can hire and fire the CEO, approve budgets, raise money and sell the company.
The board: the place where most decisions are made
Under Delaware law, which governs most US venture-backed companies, the business is managed by or under the direction of the board of directors. Stockholders elect the board but do not run the company day to day. So the question “who controls the board?” is usually more important than “who owns the most shares?”.
A typical progression looks like this:
| Stage | Common board | Who controls |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-seed / seed | 2 founders, maybe 1 investor | Founders |
| Series A | 2 common, 1 investor, or 2 common, 2 investor, 1 independent | Founders, or balanced with an independent deciding |
| Series B and later | 2 common, 2–3 investor, 1–2 independent | Often balanced or investor-leaning |
The five-seat board with an independent director is popular at Series A because it avoids a deadlock and keeps either side from simply dictating. But the independent has to be chosen by someone, and the term sheet usually says how. A common formulation is that the independent is nominated by the CEO and approved by the other directors, or chosen by mutual consent.
Watch the “CEO seat”
Many term sheets reserve one common seat for whoever is CEO. That sounds harmless until the board replaces the founder as CEO. The new CEO then takes that seat, and the founders may lose a vote at the same moment they lose the job. Some founders negotiate for both common seats to be elected by common holders, regardless of title.
Observers
Smaller investors often get board observer rights: they can attend meetings and receive materials, but cannot vote. Observers count. Every extra person in the room changes how candid a board meeting feels, so it is reasonable to limit the number and to exclude observers from sessions involving privileged legal advice or conflicts of interest.
Protective provisions: the vetoes
Protective provisions list actions the company cannot take without the approval of a specified majority of preferred stockholders, voting separately. These are rights of the investors as shareholders, not as directors, so they apply no matter who controls the board.
Standard items in the NVCA model include the right to approve:
- Selling, merging or liquidating the company.
- Amending the charter or bylaws in a way that hurts the preferred.
- Creating a new class of stock that ranks senior to or on par with the preferred.
- Buying back shares or paying dividends, with routine exceptions.
- Changing the authorised number of directors.
- Incurring debt above a stated threshold.
Those are broadly accepted, because they protect the investment itself. Trouble starts when the list drifts into operations: approving the annual budget, hiring executives, signing large customer contracts, opening offices or changing the business plan. Those decisions belong to the board, where investors already have representation.
Series-by-series vetoes
As more rounds are raised, each new investor may ask for a separate vote of “its” series. A company with three series of preferred, each holding a separate veto, can find that a minority investor with a few percent of the shares can block a sale everyone else supports. Many companies try to keep a single combined preferred vote, perhaps with a narrow series-specific vote only for changes that hurt one series differently from the others.
Ownership tells you who shares in the outcome. The board and the vetoes tell you who chooses it.
A practical checklist
- Who controls the board after this round, and after the next one if the same pattern repeats?
- How is the independent director chosen?
- Is a common seat tied to the CEO title?
- Are protective provisions limited to fundamental matters?
- What threshold of preferred holders is needed to approve? Could one investor block alone?
- How many observers, and with what limits?
Sources and further reading
Delaware General Corporation Law §141(a) on management by the board; NVCA model term sheet and voting agreement. Sample clause written by Term Sheet editors for illustration.
Before you signThis guide is general education, not legal advice. Market terms vary by country, stage and sector, and every deal is different. Have a qualified startup lawyer review any term sheet before you sign it.