New York · --:-- ET Independent · Not legal or investment advice
Control

Pro Rata, ROFR and Co-Sale: The Three Rights That Shape Every Future Round

These clauses look like housekeeping. They decide who can invest next time, who can buy a founder’s shares and who gets to sell alongside them.

A Wall Street street sign in Lower Manhattan
Photo: Acediscovery / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0) · Image credits

Some term sheet clauses only come alive years later. Pro rata rights, rights of first refusal and co-sale rights barely matter on the day you sign. They matter enormously when the company is hot, when a new lead investor wants a bigger allocation, or when a founder wants to sell a few shares to buy a flat in Brooklyn.

Pro rata rights: keeping your slice

A pro rata right, sometimes called a participation right or pre-emptive right, lets an existing investor buy enough shares in a future round to keep its ownership percentage.

Example: a seed fund owns 10 percent. The company raises a Series A that sells 20 percent of the company to new investors. Without doing anything, the seed fund drops to 8 percent. With a pro rata right, it can buy 10 percent of the new round to stay at 10 percent overall.

For investors, pro rata rights are valuable because the best companies are often the hardest to get into later. For founders, they can create friction: a new lead investor may want to buy a certain percentage, and existing investors exercising pro rata reduce what is available.

Common limits

  • Major investor threshold. Pro rata often applies only to investors above a minimum holding, so that dozens of small angels do not each hold a right.
  • Carve-outs. Shares issued to employees, in acquisitions or on conversion of existing securities do not trigger the right.
  • Super pro rata. Occasionally an investor asks to buy more than its proportional share in future rounds. This is aggressive and can deter future leads. Founders often resist it.

Right of first refusal: who can buy a seller’s shares

A right of first refusal (ROFR) means that if a shareholder, typically a founder, wants to sell shares to an outsider, the company and then the investors get the chance to buy them first, on the same terms.

Right of First Refusal: Company first and Investors second (to the extent assigned by the Board) have a right of first refusal with respect to any shares of capital stock of the Company proposed to be sold by a Founder or by employees holding greater than 1% of Company Common Stock, with a right of oversubscription for Investors of shares unsubscribed by the other Investors.

Why does this matter? It keeps the cap table under control. A company does not want a competitor, an unknown fund or hundreds of small holders appearing on its register because a founder sold shares on a secondary platform. ROFRs give the company time and a mechanism to step in.

The flip side is that a ROFR can make secondary sales slower and harder. Founders who expect to sell some shares in a later round, a common way to take money off the table without selling the company, should make sure the documents allow board-approved secondary sales without needless friction.

Co-sale (tag-along): selling alongside

A co-sale right lets investors join a founder’s sale. If a founder agrees to sell 100,000 shares to a buyer, investors with co-sale rights can insist on selling a proportional part of that number themselves, reducing how many the founder sells.

The logic: if someone is willing to pay a good price for a founder’s shares, investors want the same opportunity. It also discourages founders from cashing out quietly while investors stay locked in.

How the three fit together

RightTriggered whenWho benefitsTypical document
Pro rataThe company issues new sharesExisting investorsInvestors’ rights agreement
Right of first refusalA shareholder wants to sell existing sharesCompany, then investorsROFR and co-sale agreement
Co-sale (tag-along)A founder sells existing sharesInvestorsROFR and co-sale agreement

The secondary market twist

Over the past decade, employees and early shareholders at large private companies have increasingly sold shares through secondary platforms and tender offers. Companies have responded by tightening transfer restrictions in their bylaws and stock plans, sometimes banning sales outright without board consent. If you are an early employee, read the transfer section of your option agreement as well as the term sheet: the practical value of your shares depends on it.

These rights rarely cause fights at signing. They cause fights when someone wants to buy, or sell, at a great price.

Questions worth asking

  1. Which investors count as “major investors” for pro rata?
  2. Is there any super pro rata? Can we remove it?
  3. Does the ROFR allow board-approved secondary sales by founders up to a reasonable amount?
  4. Do these rights terminate at an IPO or acquisition?

Sources and further reading

NVCA model investors’ rights agreement and right of first refusal and co-sale agreement. Sample clause adapted in style from model documents by Term Sheet editors.

Before you signThis guide is general education, not legal advice. Market terms vary by country, stage and sector, and every deal is different. Have a qualified startup lawyer review any term sheet before you sign it.

Educational content only. Term Sheet is an independent publication. Nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Talk to a qualified lawyer before you sign anything. We are not affiliated with any law firm, venture fund, bank, trade association or other publication using a similar name.