New York · --:-- ET Independent · Not legal or investment advice
Economics

Anti-Dilution in a Down Round: Weighted Average Versus Full Ratchet, Worked Out

When a company raises money at a lower price, early investors get an adjustment. How big it is depends on one formula, and the gap between the options can be dramatic.

The columned Broad Street facade of the New York Stock Exchange
Photo: Jakub Hałun / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0) · Image credits

Nobody plans for a down round when they sign a Series A. That is exactly why the anti-dilution clause gets so little attention at the time, and why it can cause so much pain later. If the company ever has to raise money at a lower share price than an earlier round, this paragraph decides how much extra ownership the earlier investors receive, and who pays for it.

What anti-dilution actually adjusts

Preferred stock converts into common at a conversion price. At first, the conversion price equals the price the investor paid, so each preferred share converts into one common share. Anti-dilution protection lowers that conversion price if the company later sells shares more cheaply. A lower conversion price means each preferred share converts into more common shares. The extra shares come out of everybody else’s percentage, especially the founders’ and employees’.

Note what it does not protect against: ordinary dilution from raising money at a higher price. Every shareholder gets diluted in an up round; that is normal and expected. Anti-dilution only applies to issuances below the investor’s price.

The scenario

  • The company has 10,000,000 shares outstanding on a fully diluted basis, including options.
  • Of those, 2,000,000 are Series A preferred, bought at $2.00 per share ($4 million).
  • Two years later it raises $2 million of Series B at $1.00 per share, issuing 2,000,000 new shares.

Option 1: Full ratchet

The Series A conversion price drops all the way to the new price: $1.00. Each Series A share now converts into two common shares, so the 2,000,000 Series A shares convert into 4,000,000 common.

The striking thing about a full ratchet is that the size of the down round does not matter. Selling a single share at $1.00 would trigger the same adjustment as selling two million. That is why it is considered harsh, and why it is uncommon in mainstream venture deals today, though it can appear in rescue financings or very investor-friendly markets.

Option 2: Broad-based weighted average

This is the market standard in most US venture term sheets. The new conversion price is:

CP2 = CP1 × (A + B) ÷ (A + C) CP1 = conversion price before the new issue A = shares outstanding before the new issue (fully diluted, “broad-based”) B = shares the new money would have bought at CP1 C = shares actually issued in the new round

Plugging in our numbers: A is 10,000,000. B is $2,000,000 ÷ $2.00 = 1,000,000. C is 2,000,000.

CP2 = $2.00 × 11,000,000 ÷ 12,000,000 = $1.8333.

The Series A now converts into $4,000,000 ÷ $1.8333 ≈ 2,181,818 common shares, about 182,000 more than before. The adjustment reflects how much cheap stock was sold relative to the size of the company.

Option 3: Narrow-based weighted average

Same formula, but “A” counts fewer shares, sometimes only the outstanding preferred. If A is 2,000,000:

CP2 = $2.00 × 3,000,000 ÷ 4,000,000 = $1.50, so Series A converts into about 2,666,667 shares.

MethodNew conversion priceSeries A converts intoExtra shares for Series A
No protection$2.002,000,0000
Broad-based weighted average$1.83~2,181,818~181,818
Narrow-based weighted average$1.50~2,666,667~666,667
Full ratchet$1.004,000,0002,000,000

The word “broad-based” is worth fighting for. In this example it is the difference between 182,000 extra shares and 667,000.

The carve-outs

Every anti-dilution clause comes with a list of issuances that do not trigger an adjustment. Standard exceptions include:

  • Shares and options issued to employees and advisers under the approved option plan.
  • Shares issued on conversion of preferred stock or existing convertibles.
  • Shares issued in acquisitions, equipment leases or bank financings approved by the board.
  • Stock splits and dividends.

Founders should make sure the carve-out list is complete. A missing exception can turn an ordinary option grant into an accidental anti-dilution event.

Pay-to-play: the investor-side counterweight

Some term sheets add a pay-to-play provision: investors keep their anti-dilution protection, and sometimes their preferred status, only if they buy their share of the down round. It encourages existing investors to support the company when it matters most, rather than sitting back and collecting extra shares.

Anti-dilution is insurance. Broad-based weighted average is a reasonable premium. A full ratchet is closer to a penalty.

Sources and further reading

Formula and carve-outs follow the NVCA model certificate of incorporation. Worked example calculated by Term Sheet editors with rounded figures.

Before you signThis guide is general education, not legal advice. Market terms vary by country, stage and sector, and every deal is different. Have a qualified startup lawyer review any term sheet before you sign it.

Educational content only. Term Sheet is an independent publication. Nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Talk to a qualified lawyer before you sign anything. We are not affiliated with any law firm, venture fund, bank, trade association or other publication using a similar name.