New York · --:-- ET Independent · Not legal or investment advice
Economics

SAFE, Convertible Note or Priced Round? A Side-by-Side for Your First Raise

Three ways to take early money, three very different sets of obligations. We walk through each with real numbers and explain when founders and investors prefer one over another.

A street sign reading New York Stock Exchange on Broad Street
Photo: Billie Grace Ward / Wikimedia Commons (CC0) · Image credits

The first outside money into a startup usually arrives before anyone can sensibly say what the company is worth. There may be a prototype, a handful of users and a founder with a strong track record. Arguing over a precise valuation at that stage can cost more in legal fees and goodwill than it is worth. That is why three structures exist, and why picking the right one matters more than most first-time founders realise.

The three options at a glance

Post-money SAFEConvertible notePriced round
Legal formContract for future sharesDebt that converts to sharesShares issued now
Valuation set now?No; usually a capNo; usually a capYes
InterestNoneYes, accrues and convertsNone
Maturity dateNoneYes, often 12–36 monthsNone
Investor rightsMinimal; side letters commonMinimal; creditor status until conversionFull preferred rights, often a board seat
Legal cost and timeLow; daysLow to moderateHigher; weeks

The SAFE

Y Combinator introduced the Simple Agreement for Future Equity in 2013 and released a post-money version in 2018, which is now the most widely used form in the US. A SAFE is not debt. It is a promise: the investor pays now and receives shares when the company raises a priced round, usually at the lower of a valuation cap or a discount to that round’s price.

The post-money design has one big advantage for clarity. If an investor puts in $1 million on a $10 million post-money cap, it knows it will own at least 10 percent of the company immediately before the priced round, regardless of how many other SAFEs are issued. The flip side is that every additional SAFE dilutes the founders, not the earlier SAFE holders. Founders who raise on several SAFEs in a row should keep a running pro forma table so the total does not surprise them.

Common add-ons include a most-favoured-nation (MFN) clause, which lets an early holder adopt better terms given to later SAFE investors, and a side letter granting pro rata rights in the next round.

The convertible note

A note is a loan. It carries interest, has a maturity date and converts into equity in a qualifying financing, typically with a discount and a cap. Here is how the numbers can work out.

  • An angel lends $500,000 at 6 percent simple interest, with a 20 percent discount and an $8 million cap.
  • Twelve months later the company raises a Series A at $2.00 per share, with 8,000,000 fully diluted shares before the round.
  • Discount price: $2.00 × 0.8 = $1.60. Cap price: $8,000,000 ÷ 8,000,000 = $1.00.
  • The note converts at the lower price, $1.00. Principal plus a year’s interest is $530,000, so the angel receives 530,000 shares, while new investors pay $2.00 for theirs.

The maturity date is the part founders forget. If no priced round happens before maturity, the holder can in theory demand repayment. In practice most noteholders extend or convert rather than push a young company into insolvency, but the leverage exists, and it tends to surface at awkward moments.

The priced round

Here the company sells preferred stock at an agreed price, with a full term sheet covering liquidation preference, protective provisions, board seats and the rest. It takes longer and costs more, but everyone knows exactly what they own on day one. Institutional seed funds increasingly lead small priced rounds, often using standardised “Series Seed” documents to keep costs down.

Choosing between them

SituationOften the better fit
Small angel cheques arriving over several monthsSAFE
Investors who need a debt instrument for tax or regulatory reasonsConvertible note
A bridge between two priced rounds with existing investorsConvertible note or SAFE
A lead investor writing a large cheque and wanting a board seatPriced round
Founders who want certainty about dilutionPriced round, or very carefully tracked SAFEs

Outside the United States

The SAFE is a US invention built around Delaware corporate law, and it does not travel perfectly. UK founders often use the Advance Subscription Agreement, partly so investors can keep SEIS/EIS tax relief. Canadian, Singaporean and Australian ecosystems have local adaptations. Several countries have securities or exchange-control rules that make a plain US SAFE impractical. Ask a local lawyer before borrowing a US template.

A SAFE is simple to sign and easy to forget. The dilution it creates is not.

Sources and further reading

Y Combinator’s published SAFE documents and user guide; NVCA and Series Seed model documents; UK Advance Subscription Agreement guidance from SEIS/EIS practitioners. Note conversion example calculated by Term Sheet editors with simple interest.

Before you signThis guide is general education, not legal advice. Market terms vary by country, stage and sector, and every deal is different. Have a qualified startup lawyer review any term sheet before you sign it.

Educational content only. Term Sheet is an independent publication. Nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Talk to a qualified lawyer before you sign anything. We are not affiliated with any law firm, venture fund, bank, trade association or other publication using a similar name.