New York · --:-- ET Independent · Not legal or investment advice
Economics

Pre-Money, Post-Money and the Option Pool Shuffle: Where Valuations Quietly Shrink

A $20 million pre-money valuation can turn into $16.25 million without anyone changing the headline number. The difference is one sentence about the option pool.

Sand Hill Road in Menlo Park, California, lined with trees
Photo: Antti T. Nissinen / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0) · Image credits

Ask a founder what their company was valued at in its last round and you will get a number. Ask how many shares the investors bought and at what price, and the conversation often goes quiet. The headline valuation and the price actually paid are related, but they are not the same thing, and the gap between them is where a lot of dilution hides.

The basic arithmetic

Start with three definitions that every term sheet relies on:

  • Pre-money valuation: the value the parties agree the company is worth immediately before the new investment.
  • Investment: the new cash coming in.
  • Post-money valuation: pre-money plus investment.

The investor’s ownership after closing is simply the investment divided by the post-money valuation. If a fund invests $5 million at a $20 million pre-money valuation, the post-money is $25 million and the fund owns 20 percent.

The price per share is the pre-money valuation divided by the number of shares outstanding before the round, on a fully diluted basis. And that phrase, “fully diluted”, is where things get interesting.

What counts as “fully diluted”?

Fully diluted capitalisation counts every share that exists or could exist: common stock, preferred stock, issued options, warrants and, in many term sheets, convertible notes and SAFEs that will convert in the round. It also usually counts the unallocated option pool: shares reserved for future employee grants that nobody owns yet.

Here is a typical sentence from a term sheet:

Price per share of $[__] (the “Original Purchase Price”), based on a pre-money valuation of $20,000,000 on a fully diluted basis, including an available option pool equal to 15% of the post-closing fully diluted capitalization.

Read it twice. The pool is “included” in the pre-money. That means the shares for the pool are created before the investor buys in, and their cost falls entirely on the existing shareholders.

The shuffle, in numbers

Take the same $5 million investment at a $20 million pre-money, with a requirement that the unallocated pool equal 15 percent of the company after closing.

Pool inside pre-money (typical term sheet)Pool added after the round
Post-money valuation$25.0M$25.0M
Investor ownership20.0%17.0%
Option pool15.0%15.0%
Founders & existing holders65.0%68.0%
Value of the pool carved from the pre-money15% × $25M = $3.75M—
Effective pre-money for existing holders$16.25M$20.0M

In the first column, the existing shareholders are effectively selling their company for $16.25 million, not $20 million, because $3.75 million of “their” pre-money value is actually new shares for future employees. In the second column, the investor shares the cost of the pool. The difference here is three percentage points of founder ownership, which is real money in any good outcome.

Venture investors are not being sneaky by asking for the first structure. It is the market norm in most US deals, and there is a fair argument behind it: the pool is there to hire the team the investor’s money is funding, and the investor does not want its fresh shares diluted immediately by grants it agreed to pay for. But founders should understand the effect and negotiate it consciously.

How to push back sensibly

  1. Size the pool to a hiring plan. Build a list of the roles you expect to fill before the next round and the typical grant for each. If that adds up to 9 percent, a 15 percent pool is a giveaway.
  2. Count what you already have. Unallocated options from earlier rounds should count toward the target.
  3. Trade valuation for pool. A higher headline price with a bigger pool and a lower headline price with a smaller pool can produce the same effective pre-money. Compare effective numbers, not headlines.
  4. Use the Deal Lab. Our calculator shows the effective pre-money as you move the pool slider.

Convertibles: the second hidden layer

SAFEs and convertible notes complicate things further. When they convert into the priced round, they add shares. If the term sheet says the pre-money valuation “includes” all converting securities, then their dilution also falls on the founders rather than the new investor. With several SAFEs outstanding, this can move ownership by more than the pool does. Always ask your lawyer for a pro forma cap table showing every holder before and after the round.

Never compare two term sheets on headline valuation alone. Compare the price per share and the founders’ percentage after closing.

A quick checklist

  • Is the option pool inside or outside the pre-money?
  • Is the pool target measured pre-closing or post-closing?
  • Are existing unallocated options counted toward the target?
  • Do converting SAFEs and notes sit inside the pre-money?
  • What are the founders’ percentages after closing, in a real pro forma table?

Sources and further reading

Worked example calculated by Term Sheet editors. Definitions follow the NVCA model term sheet. The “option pool shuffle” label was popularised by venture investors writing about founder dilution in the late 2000s and is now common usage.

Before you signThis guide is general education, not legal advice. Market terms vary by country, stage and sector, and every deal is different. Have a qualified startup lawyer review any term sheet before you sign it.

Educational content only. Term Sheet is an independent publication. Nothing here is legal, tax or investment advice, and reading it does not create an attorney–client relationship. Talk to a qualified lawyer before you sign anything. We are not affiliated with any law firm, venture fund, bank, trade association or other publication using a similar name.